How to Convert a Regular Recipe to Sourdough - Hilltop Farmhouse (2024)

Sometimes I find a yummy bread recipe (this could be muffins, sandwich bread, tortillas, etc) and decide I want to try it out, but I’d also like to find a way to make it a little healthier.

There are a few options for achieving that goal: replace the sugar with a natural sweetener like honey or maple syrup, or convert the recipe to sourdough.

How exactly do you change a regular recipe to a sourdough recipe? This is something I asked myself many times. The solution seemed very daunting, so I put it off for so long. But one day I decided that I was going to figure this out so I could make any recipe I wanted into sourdough.

Here are a few recipes that I’ve turned into sourdough options: Chocolate Chip Muffins, Pancakes, Waffles, Red Lobster Biscuits, Pizza Crust, and so much more!

Learn how to take any bread recipe and make it into sourdough! Now you can have sourdough bread, waffles, crackers, biscuits, and whatever else your heart desires! Just follow these basic rules to convert any recipe to sourdough. I also include info on starting your own sourdough starter and why it is so healthy for you! You’ll also find a list of more sourdough recipes at the very end of this post.

How to Convert A Regular Recipe to Sourdough

The Basics

• 100 grams of sourdough starter = 5 to 7 grams of instant/dry yeast (this would be one packet).
• Sourdough starter is a liquid, so the amount of liquids in a recipe must be decreased by 1 cup when you convert it to a sourdough recipe.
• Reduce the amount of flour by 1 cup.
• Fermentation time is doubled compared to a regular bread recipe.

These are the basic principles to converting recipes to sourdough, but each recipe requires some unique adjustments. Trust me, if you follow these guidelines and practice, you will soon understand how to make any recipe into sourdough!

Why Would I Want to Convert a Recipe to Sourdough?

Sourdough is a fermented food, making it impressively nutritious. Your sourdough bread breaks down proteins as it ferments. This breakdown results in amino acids that are so much easier for your body to digest. Read more about this process and the benefitshere.

Converting A Yeast Recipe to Sourdough

This includes traditional breads that call for yeast.

The Basics:

• Replace one packet of yeast with 100 grams of sourdough starter.
• Reduce the flour by 1 cup.
• Reduce the amount of liquid by 1 cup.
• Allow to ferment and rise for 8-24 hours.

Example:

I decreased all the liquid items by 1 cup total (give or take a bit) and reduced the flour by 1 cup as well.

Converting Non-Yeast Based Recipes to Sourdough

This includes quickbread items like muffins, cupcakes, cookies, tortillas, crackers, banana bread, waffles, pancakes, etc.

Keep in mind: These kinds of recipes do not call for yeast, so they use baking soda or baking powder to help them rise.

Adding baking soda and baking powder at the end will help the quickbread rise best!

The Basics:

1. Reduce the flour by 1 cup.
2. Reduce the water/liquid by 1 cup.
3. Add in the baking soda and baking powder last, right before baking.
4. Allow it to ferment for at least 4 hours in order to maximize health benefits.

Example:

I have a recipe for Cheddar Biscuits and I’d like to change it to sourdough. Here’s how I achieved that goal:

I’ve put the changes in italics.

Keep in Mind: This is an example of a conversion I have done with success, but each time I make it I have to adjust a bit. My sourdough starter is always changing (more hydrated or less hydrated), so sometimes I add more flour if the batter is too sticky, or I’ll add a little milk if it is very dry.

I encourage you to know your starter. Is it very hydrated than normal? If so, you may end up with a sticky batter or dough. Is your starter less hydrated than normal? Then it’ll probably produce a drier product. Adjust the recipe as needed!

What if My Original Recipe Only Calls For 1 Cup of Flour and Water/Liquid?

Sometimes a non-sourdough recipe only calls for 1 cup of flour and 1 cup of water/liquid. Just replace all of it with sourdough starter.

Keep in mind: If you do this to a recipe, there is no reason to allow it to ferment for 4+ hours because there is no longer any flour in the mixture to break down!

Can I Use Sourdough AND Traditional Yeast?

There are two answers to this question. Each one depends on the reason you’d like to add sourdough.

1. Just for the yummy flavor of sourdough. Then go ahead! Add a little to your recipe and you’ll end up with the taste of sourdough.
2. For the health benefits of fermentation! Adding yeast to sourdough will stop the process of fermentation, which is what makes sourdough so healthy. If you want the health benefits, don’t add yeast!

Keep in Mind

• Sourdough never needs to be ‘punched down’ like regular bread dough does. The long rise time will be undone if punched down.
• These are a few things I have learned through experimentation, but please note that every sourdough starter is different (based on climate). Follow these guidelines, but you may also need to make adjustments based on your starter. I encourage you to practice and get to know your sourdough starter. Soon you’ll know exactly what it prefers!
• Sugar. The process of fermentation does not work as well when lots of sugar is present in a recipe. Cakes are a good example of this since they often call for a large amount of sugar. Feel free to add some sourdough for the flavor of it, but be aware that the health benefits of fermentation will not be there.

How Can I Make My Own Sourdough Starter?

Interested in implementing sourdough into your kitchen?Here’severything you need to know to get your sourdough starter going.

All it takes is flour, water, and about 7 days time.

I also answer a few of the most frequently asked questions about sourdough overhere.

How is Sourdough Healthier than Regular Bread?

Read more in depth about the health benefits of sourdough here. I explain four reasons that sourdough is one of the healthiest breads you can consume, as well as describe how the fermentation process of sourdough works.

More Sourdough Recipes

• Naturally Sweetened Sourdough Pancakes
• Naturally Sweetened Sourdough Waffles
• Honey-Sweetened Sourdough Chocolate Chip Muffins
• Sourdough Discard Crackers

Pin it For Later!